The Stagecoach Tavern

“The worst Pastrami / Corned Beef Reuben I have ever had.”

I had heard good reports about the food and atmosphere at The Stage Coach Tavern, and so on my last trip to New York towards the end of February, I decided to try it, specifically for the Pastrami or Corn Beef Reuben they served.

What a bitter disappointment.

Somehow they managed to make the rye bread soggy as well as toasted.

The Pastrami / Corned Beef was there but somewhat less than I expected, judging from other deli’s I had eaten at, and I am sure I did taste a smidgen of sauerkraut on the sandwich.

There absolutely was cheese on there but whether it was a good Swiss cheese is a moot point.

All in all a totally forgettable experience.

Oh, their draft beers were good.

Date of visit: February 2017

Value – 3/5
Service – 4/5
Food – 1/5

Visit website

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *